Skip to content
FREE SHIPPING FOR ORDERS OVER $50
FREE SHIPPING FOR ORDERS OVER $50

Best Selling

  • Premium Main Flavor

    Buckeye

    from $11.00

    Paying homage to our origins, Shirley’s Buckeye popcorn combines rich milk chocolate and peanut butter flavoring atop our rich classic Caramel To D...

    View full details
  • Classic Main Flavor

    Caramel To Die For

    from $7.00

    Shirley Torsell admired quality - she had a way of finding the softest teddy bears, the most captivating children's stories, the most brilliant ill...

    View full details
  • Premium Main Flavor

    Dark Salted Caramel

    from $11.00

    Dark Salted Caramel starts with our buttery Caramel To Die For™ popcorn.  Then we drizzle dark chocolate over top for just the right amount of swee...

    View full details
  • Classic Main Flavor

    Windy City Style

    from $7.00

    One of our founder’s favorites! With equal parts of our classic cheddar and our rich Caramel To Die For™, our Windy City Style popcorn is the perfe...

    View full details
  • Classic Main Flavor

    Jelly Bean

    from $7.00

    What started out as a flavor of the month turned into an amazingly popular & fun core flavor! We’ve mixed six fruit flavors (lemon, orange, blu...

    View full details
  • Classic Main Flavor

    Cheddar

    from $7.00

    This flavor begins with our classic theatre-style popcorn, and then is carefully coated with our deep classic cheddar flavoring.

  • Original Main Flavor

    Theatre Style

    from $5.00

    It's how we got our start, popping natural goodness that'll take your senses right into our theatre's lobby.

  • Classic Main Flavor

    Caramel Nut Cluster

    from $7.00

    Caramel Nut Cluster started out as a flavor of the month - and is based on years of requests for a flavor that combines our rich, smooth classic Ca...

    View full details
  • Classic Main Flavor

    White Cheddar

    from $7.00

    This flavor begins with our classic theatre-style popcorn, and then is carefully coated with our mild white cheddar flavoring.

  • Premium Main Flavor

    Chocolate Almond

    from $11.00

    Caramel To Die For™ popcorn topped off with roasted almonds and rich milk chocolate! Literally one of the best recipes ever created!

  • Classic Main Flavor

    Afterburner

    from $7.00

    Put on your seatbelt and have a drink handy! Although it starts out smooth and sweet, our Afterburner popcorn lights up your taste-buds only moment...

    View full details
  • Classic Regional Flavor

    Polar Pop

    from $7.00

    Named for Ohio Northern University’s mascot (a polar bear), Polar Pop is an equal mix of our classic & white cheddar popcorn flavors. It’s a gr...

    View full details
  • Premium Regional Flavor

    UNOH Crunch

    from $11.00

    **Only available in the Lima location. Not available in other locations. UNOH Crunch popcorn features maroon-colored candy coated popcorn topped wi...

    View full details
  • Premium Regional Flavor

    Duke Dog Crunch

    from $11.00

    **Only available for pick-up in the Harrisonburg location.  Not available for shipping, or in other locations.** For anyone who has been to the She...

    View full details
  • Premium Regional Flavor

    Flag City Crunch

    from $11.00

    **Only available for pickup in the Findlay location. Not available for shipping or in other locations.** Created specifically for Flag City, USA (A...

    View full details
  • Premium Regional Flavor

    Oiler Nation Select

    from $11.00

    **Only available for pick-up in the Findlay location. Not available for shipping or in other locations.** This flavor, created by the University of...

    View full details
  • Premium Regional Flavor

    Cardy Corn

    from $11.00

    **Only available for pick-up in the Westerville location.  Not available for shipping, or in other locations.** Paying homage to Otterbein Universi...

    View full details
  • Premium Regional Flavor

    Klondike Krunch

    from $11.00

    **Only available for pickup in the Bluffton location. Not available in other locations.** Hailing to the Ohio Northern University mascot, our Klond...

    View full details
  • Premium Regional Flavor

    Rhodes Ready Pop

    from $11.00

    **Only available for pick-up in the Lima location. Not available for shipping or pick-up in other locations.** Created for Rhodes State College in ...

    View full details
  • Classic Regional Flavor

    Rockin' Royal

    from $7.00

    **Only available for pick-up in the Harrisonburg location. Not available for shipping, or for pick-up in other locations.** Not to be outdone by ot...

    View full details
  • Premium Featured Flavor

    Pina Colada

    from $11.00

    Our 2021 Associate Cookoff Winner!  This popcorn is an ode to everything summer & tropical!  One taste of this coconut and pineapple popcorn wi...

    View full details
  • Classic Featured Flavor

    Red Hot Cinnamon

    from $7.00

    Shirley's Red Hot Cinnamon popcorn is as hot as it is red...and perfect to keep your snacks as sweltering as your summer days.  Don't miss your opp...

    View full details
Liquid error: Could not find asset snippets/th-subscription-scripts.liquid