Skip to content
FREE SHIPPING FOR ORDERS OVER $50
FREE SHIPPING FOR ORDERS OVER $50

Best Selling

  • Premium Main Flavor

    Buckeye

    from $11.00

    Paying homage to our origins, Shirley’s Buckeye popcorn combines rich milk chocolate and peanut butter flavoring atop our rich classic Caramel To D...

    View full details
  • Classic Main Flavor

    Caramel To Die For

    from $7.00

    Shirley Torsell admired quality - she had a way of finding the softest teddy bears, the most captivating children's stories, the most brilliant ill...

    View full details
  • Premium Main Flavor

    Dark Salted Caramel

    from $11.00

    Dark Salted Caramel starts with our buttery Caramel To Die For™ popcorn.  Then we drizzle dark chocolate over top for just the right amount of swee...

    View full details
  • Classic Main Flavor

    Windy City Style

    from $7.00

    One of our founder’s favorites! With equal parts of our classic cheddar and our rich Caramel To Die For™, our Windy City Style popcorn is the perfe...

    View full details
  • Classic Main Flavor

    Jelly Bean

    from $7.00

    What started out as a flavor of the month turned into an amazingly popular & fun core flavor! We’ve mixed six fruit flavors (lemon, orange, blu...

    View full details
  • Classic Main Flavor

    Cheddar

    from $7.00

    This flavor begins with our classic theatre-style popcorn, and then is carefully coated with our deep classic cheddar flavoring.

  • Original Main Flavor

    Theatre Style

    from $5.00

    It's how we got our start, popping natural goodness that'll take your senses right into our theatre's lobby.

  • Classic Main Flavor

    Caramel Nut Cluster

    from $7.00

    Caramel Nut Cluster started out as a flavor of the month - and is based on years of requests for a flavor that combines our rich, smooth classic Ca...

    View full details
  • Classic Main Flavor

    White Cheddar

    from $7.00

    This flavor begins with our classic theatre-style popcorn, and then is carefully coated with our mild white cheddar flavoring.

  • Premium Main Flavor

    Chocolate Almond

    from $11.00

    Caramel To Die For™ popcorn topped off with roasted almonds and rich milk chocolate! Literally one of the best recipes ever created!

  • Classic Main Flavor

    Afterburner

    from $7.00

    Put on your seatbelt and have a drink handy! Although it starts out smooth and sweet, our Afterburner popcorn lights up your taste-buds only moment...

    View full details
  • Classic Regional Flavor

    Polar Pop

    from $7.00

    Named for Ohio Northern University’s mascot (a polar bear), Polar Pop is an equal mix of our classic & white cheddar popcorn flavors. It’s a gr...

    View full details
  • Premium Regional Flavor

    UNOH Crunch

    from $11.00

    **Only available in the Lima location. Not available in other locations. UNOH Crunch popcorn features maroon-colored candy coated popcorn topped wi...

    View full details
  • Premium Regional Flavor

    Duke Dog Crunch

    from $11.00

    **Only available for pick-up in the Harrisonburg location.  Not available for shipping, or in other locations.** For anyone who has been to the She...

    View full details
  • Premium Regional Flavor

    Flag City Crunch

    from $11.00

    **Only available for pickup in the Findlay location. Not available for shipping or in other locations.** Created specifically for Flag City, USA (A...

    View full details
  • Premium Regional Flavor

    Oiler Nation Select

    from $11.00

    **Only available for pick-up in the Findlay location. Not available for shipping or in other locations.** This flavor, created by the University of...

    View full details
  • Premium Regional Flavor

    Cardy Corn

    from $11.00

    **Only available for pick-up in the Westerville location.  Not available for shipping, or in other locations.** Paying homage to Otterbein Universi...

    View full details
  • Premium Regional Flavor

    Klondike Krunch

    from $11.00

    **Only available for pickup in the Bluffton location. Not available in other locations.** Hailing to the Ohio Northern University mascot, our Klond...

    View full details
  • Premium Regional Flavor

    Rhodes Ready Pop

    from $11.00

    **Only available for pick-up in the Lima location. Not available for shipping or pick-up in other locations.** Created for Rhodes State College in ...

    View full details
  • Classic Regional Flavor

    Rockin' Royal

    from $7.00

    **Only available for pick-up in the Harrisonburg location. Not available for shipping, or for pick-up in other locations.** Not to be outdone by ot...

    View full details
  • Premium Featured Flavor

    Key Lime Pie

    from $11.00

    We turned this spring pie staple into a spring popcorn staple! Starting with sweet candy-coated popcorn, we add graham crackers, white chocolate, a...

    View full details
  • Premium Featured Flavor

    Lemon Cheesecake

    from $11.00

    Indulge in this new sweet delight originally created by two of our own Fallen Timbers team members! We add the taste of cheesecake to Shirley's lem...

    View full details